Forbiddens

Dear Azeem

I am not in a very good position to answer these Qs due to my lack of knowledge (JEHAL). I can't confirm these references as well because in office I don’t have much time.. But what i would mention is about IMAMAT. I can say without any doubt that excluding high Ranks Scholars no one from general Tshiyoo public knows much about the Wilayt o Imamat. Particularly about the ISRAR-e-IMAMAT which are clandestine. And this is right too because as per Imam Our relations with Allah couldn’t be understood by anyone except a Nabi-e-Mursel, a Malik-e-Muqarab and a Momin whose heart has strongly been tested by Allah and in some Riwayat it has been prohibited too to explain these facts (Secrets) in front of general public. Therefore normally scholars deny these Riwayat.

But you can see Imam Khomaine didn’t do this. He wrote whatever he got…….. I was amazed to read his book Sahrah Junood e Aqal wa Jehal in which whatever he has written can never be expressed. A complied transcripts in an Urdu book Imamat wa Insan -e- Kamil has answers of all of your Qs. Imama Khomaine once asked from his teacher Ayatuallah Shah Abadi Q.S that why do you revealed these secrets in front of general people (Ye log aur ye batain). Aogha replied I want these to listen these forbiddens (main chahta hoon k ye kufriyat in k kano main bhi patr jain too acha ha) (Sair 0 Salook – Urdu translation)

As Imam Khomiane Q.s said don’t disagree with one which you don’t know (Sair 0 Salook – Urdu translation)

Regards
Mujtaba